Positive Report Card Comments for Struggling Students (That Stay Honest)
How to write comments that give parents hope without hiding the truth, with 35 examples by subject and situation: 29 complete comments and 6 sentence starters.
Writing these for a whole class? The Report Card Comment Library fills in each student’s name for you and lets you search 374 comments. Try 20 free with no sign-up. The full set is $4.99 once.
There is a specific kind of dread that comes with opening the comment box for a student who is drowning. You know the parent will read this. You know the kid might read it someday. You know "needs improvement" is a cop-out and "significantly below grade level in all areas" reads like a verdict.
I have written that comment many times, and I have also been on the receiving end of report cards as a parent. So let me offer the frame that finally made these comments easier to write.
The parent of a struggling student is not looking for a grade. They already suspect. What they are looking for, reading your comment at the kitchen table, is the answer to three questions:

- Does this teacher see anything good in my kid?
- How bad is it, really?
- Is anyone doing anything about it?
Answer all three and you have written a great comment. Skip the first one and the parent stops reading. Skip the second and you have lied. Skip the third and you have handed them despair. Below are 29 complete report card comments and 6 sentence starters. The examples describe student strengths, academic challenges, progress, and classroom supports that teachers can personalize.
These are customizable examples. Adjust the details about student progress, classroom supports, and interventions to reflect your own observations and records.
Struggling readers
- "[Name] listens attentively during read-alouds and demonstrates a good understanding of stories discussed in class. Reading unfamiliar words independently remains challenging. Small-group reading instruction has helped [Name] improve word recognition and decoding skills."
- "[Name] continues to work on reading accuracy and fluency. Reading familiar passages more than once and practicing high-frequency words have helped [Name] read with greater accuracy. Continued practice will help strengthen these skills."
- "[Name] contributes thoughtful ideas during class discussions and answers questions about stories read aloud. Reading unfamiliar words independently continues to be challenging. Targeted practice with decoding skills is helping [Name] become a more independent reader."
- "[Name] has begun choosing books to read independently during classroom reading time. Although [Name] continues to read below grade level, regular small-group instruction and practice with foundational reading skills are helping [Name] make progress."
Struggling writers
- "[Name] shares detailed ideas and stories during class discussions but has difficulty organizing those ideas in writing. Sentence starters and graphic organizers have helped [Name] write longer, more complete responses."
- "[Name] shares creative ideas through writing and contributes interesting details to stories. Spelling errors sometimes make written work difficult to understand. Regular practice with high-frequency words and spelling patterns is helping [Name] improve written communication."
- "[Name] has made progress writing more complete responses. Earlier in the year, [Name] often wrote only a few words before stopping. With the help of sentence starters and a writing checklist, [Name] is now producing several sentences and working toward writing a complete paragraph."
- "[Name] has difficulty getting started on independent writing assignments but contributes thoughtful ideas during class discussions. We are using shorter writing tasks and graphic organizers to help [Name] plan ideas and begin writing more independently."
Need to find the right one faster, across every category? The Report Card Comment Library is a separate tool, built for getting through a whole class.
This page Free
- Scroll the list to find one that fits
- Swap in each student’s name yourself
- No sign-up
The library $4.99 once
- Type the name once and it fills into every comment
- Search by keyword, or filter by tone and grade band
- 374 comments: Behavior, ADHD / Attention, Preschool, Academics, Social-Emotional
No sign-up to try it. All 374 comments are a one-time $4.99, no subscription.
Struggling math students
- "[Name] demonstrates a good understanding of numbers during real-world activities, especially those involving money. Solving multi-step word problems remains challenging. Breaking problems into smaller steps and identifying important information have helped [Name] work through problems more successfully."
- "[Name] has become more consistent about asking questions when additional help is needed. Recalling basic math facts quickly and accurately remains an area for improvement. Daily practice and review are helping [Name] strengthen math fact fluency."
- "[Name] is currently performing below grade-level expectations in math. Small-group instruction and additional guided practice are helping [Name] strengthen foundational skills. We will continue reviewing previously taught concepts and monitoring progress toward grade-level expectations."
- "[Name] participates in math lessons and can demonstrate understanding of new concepts with guidance. Applying those same skills after several days without practice remains challenging. Regular review and a math reference notebook have helped [Name] remember and use previously learned strategies."
Work completion and organization
- "[Name] produces thoughtful, accurate work when assignments are completed. Finishing tasks within the allotted time remains challenging. Visual checklists and breaking assignments into smaller steps have helped [Name] complete more classroom work independently."
- "[Name] completes assignments successfully with individual guidance but has difficulty staying on task during independent work. Shorter assignments, visual reminders, and regular teacher check-ins have helped [Name] complete more work without direct assistance."
- "[Name] has made progress organizing classroom materials and remembering to bring assignments between home and school. Using a daily folder and following a consistent classroom routine have helped [Name] keep track of materials more independently."
- "[Name] has made noticeable progress staying on task during independent assignments. Earlier in the year, [Name] typically worked independently for about five minutes before needing a reminder. [Name] can now remain focused for approximately fifteen minutes, and we will continue working toward longer periods of independent work."
Confidence and Classroom Participation
- "[Name] attempts challenging assignments more often before asking for help. Although some academic skills still require additional practice, [Name] is beginning more tasks independently and using classroom resources when needed."
- "[Name] is participating more frequently in class discussions, volunteering answers, and attempting challenging problems. Academic performance remains below grade-level expectations, but increased participation provides more opportunities for [Name] to practice and demonstrate developing skills."
- "[Name] has made progress with classroom participation and work completion since the beginning of the year. Although some academic skills are still developing, [Name] is completing more assignments and contributing more frequently during lessons."
- "[Name] continues working on challenging assignments and makes use of teacher support when needed. Although some academic skills remain below grade level, [Name] is completing more tasks and showing improvement with regular practice and guidance."
Comments for students working below grade level
"Below grade level" is the phrase parents brace for, so it needs the same three answers wrapped around it: something good, the honest picture, and the plan.
- "[Name] is currently reading below grade level but is making progress with foundational reading skills. Daily small-group instruction and regular practice with decoding and high-frequency words have helped [Name] improve reading accuracy. We will continue monitoring progress and targeting skills that need additional support."
- "[Name] is currently working below grade level in reading and math. Targeted small-group instruction and additional practice are helping [Name] strengthen foundational skills in both subjects. We will continue monitoring progress and providing support in areas of difficulty."
- "[Name] began the year performing significantly below grade-level expectations in [subject]. Recent classroom work and assessments show improvement, and [Name] is now approaching grade-level expectations. Continued instruction and practice will help build on this progress."
- "[Name] is making progress with grade-level concepts when provided with appropriate instructional supports. Breaking assignments into smaller steps and providing additional guidance have helped [Name] demonstrate understanding and complete classroom work more successfully. We will continue using supports that meet [Name]'s learning needs."
- "[Name] is currently working below grade-level expectations in [subject]. Additional instruction through [specific intervention or program] is helping [Name] develop foundational skills. We will continue monitoring progress and adjusting instruction based on [Name]'s individual needs."
- "[Name] continues to perform below grade-level expectations in [subject] but has made noticeable academic progress this term. Recent assignments and assessments show improvement in skills that were challenging earlier in the year. Continued targeted instruction will help [Name] build on this growth."
When Work Completion and Engagement Are Challenging
The hardest comment to write is for the student who is behind and also has missing or incomplete assignments, difficulty starting tasks, or inconsistent participation. Manufactured praise fails here. Find what is true, and be plain about the rest:
- "[Name] has demonstrated the ability to complete quality work with teacher guidance. However, incomplete and missing assignments are affecting academic progress. We are working on a consistent routine for starting and finishing assignments and will continue monitoring work completion."
- "[Name] is a kind and helpful classmate who frequently assists others during classroom activities. Completing academic assignments consistently remains a challenge. Daily goals and regular feedback have helped [Name] make progress with work completion."
- "[Name] contributes positively during classroom activities but has difficulty staying on task during independent assignments. Clear expectations, shorter tasks, and regular teacher check-ins have helped [Name] complete more work independently."
Quick lines to open any comment
These six are sentence starters, not complete report card comments. Every struggling student has something true and good to lead with. If you are stuck, open with one of these, then add the honest picture and the plan:
- "[Name] brings a wonderful sense of humor to our classroom."
- "[Name] consistently treats classmates with kindness and respect."
- "[Name] arrives prepared and ready to participate in classroom activities."
- "[Name] continues working on challenging assignments and asks for help when needed."
- "[Name] has become more independent with classroom routines since the beginning of the year."
- "[Name] contributes thoughtful ideas during classroom discussions."
The phrases to avoid
A few translations, learned over many report card seasons:
- Instead of: "Weak student." Write: "Working below grade level in [specific skill]."
- Instead of: "Lazy" or "unmotivated." Write: "Effort is inconsistent, and we are working on it with [specific support]."
- Instead of: "Struggles with everything." Write: the two priority areas, with the plan for each. A comment naming everything fixes nothing.
- Instead of: "Doesn't care." Write: what you observe, not what you infer: "rarely completes independent work" is observable; "doesn't care" is a guess about a child's heart, and it is usually wrong.
If the struggle is primarily behavioral rather than academic, we have a full set of report card comments for behavior. And if the student has ADHD or you suspect attention is the root, the strength-based ADHD comment templates handle that specific wording challenge.
Write the phone call before the comment
One rule above all: the report card should never be breaking news. If a student is genuinely struggling, the parent hears it from your voice first. The mid-term progress report is the other place parents should see it coming; these student progress report comments are built for those check-ins. The comment then becomes easy, because it is just a summary of a conversation you have already had. If that call is the part you dread, this script for calling a parent about behavior adapts well to academic conversations too.
Where the specifics come from
Every strong example above leans on a detail: the fifteen minutes of focused work, the move from a few words to several sentences, the math reference notebook. You cannot conjure those in June. You can only write them down when they happen, and the teacher's complete guide to documenting student behavior shows how to make that a habit that survives a full year.
That is the entire idea behind ShortHand. A ten-second note on your phone in the moment ("finished the whole page independently, first time") becomes the raw material for report card comments, parent emails, and intervention documentation later. When it is time to write about a struggling student, you are not staring at a blank box trying to be fair from memory. Your own observations are right there, and they already tell the story: honestly, specifically, and with the progress visible.
Try ShortHand free. The kids who struggle deserve the best-written comments on the page. And if reports are due before you can build the note-taking habit, the free report card comment generator will draft one for you right now, no sign-up needed.
Gregory Lebed is a 3rd grade teacher with 20+ years in education and a former Registered Behavior Technician. He built ShortHand to help teachers spend less time on paperwork and more time teaching.
Still have most of your class to write? The Report Card Comment Library is built for getting through a whole class. Type a student’s name once and it fills into every comment, then search or filter to the one that fits and copy it.
No sign-up to try it. All 374 comments are a one-time $4.99, no subscription.
Frequently Asked Questions
Stop trying to remember everything.
Try ShortHand Free →